Nine months isn't too long between posts, right?
This is the contents of a brainstorming post on G+. Its some musings about the Pioneer GUI and where to take it. If you've only been reading this blog then you've missed all the work I've done on this in the last few months. Ask if you're interested and I'll throw some pointers your way. Also there's updates on the G+ post, so keep reading that. The modern world of blogging at its finest..
Anyway, I know visually what I want, and its basically what jQuery gives you out of the box - nice swishy transitions, zooms, etc. I think the model is appropriate since we want to expose some parts of this to scripts, but even in core it'd be wonderful to just say "slide this widget onto the screen and once its there, call this method".
In the long-term I'm intending to move Pioneer away from its 800x600 virtual screen, mostly because it looks like shit on a really high-res widescreen monitor. So my intention is that positioning will be done as 0.0-1.0 in x, 0.0-1.0 in y, measured against a chosen container edge. Scaling by default will be aspect-aware, so I can say that a particular image (quad) should use 10% of the horizontal width and its height will do the right thing.
I'm pretty sure I want a fluid layout, where widgets ask for a minimum/ideal/maximum amount of space and are then handed out an amount depending on the layout strategy of the container they're in. This is not so different to what we have now, but we don't use it in a lot of places. I want fixed position to be used very very sparingly, mostly where precise positioning is required, like control panel buttons.
Scrollbars should be automatic at the container level. If scrolling is enabled for a container then it will give out the maximum possible width/height to each component (based on its requested dimensions).
I like the model Unity uses for its UI where each widget has a corresponding style component. This also gives a convenient place for transitions to hook - they simply modify styles. To do positoning or zooming-type animations I think I don't want to try to modify the widget's metrics, but rather apply a transform at draw time.
I'm still not sure how font metrics feed into widget metrics. I've been assuming for a while that I need a way for a widget to say it wants a height of N lines of text, but whenever I try to think of a clear example I can't. Perhaps I don't care - perhaps it just needs to say "I'll take all of the vertical space you can give me, and please scroll me if I blow it". Though I can see that text layout needs to know whether it should prioritise width over height or vice-versa when doing wrapping.
I've done a good amount of research and experimentation with various GUI systems, both for Pioneer itself (Rocket, GWEN, Guichan, etc) and elsewhere (GTK+, jQuery, Zune, etc). They all have things I like and don't like, which is why I think this has gone on so long.
So basically I think I want to do the lightest and most obvious design possible and see what falls out. That's proving a little more painful than I'd like because Pioneer's GUI has way too much global state which has to be fixed first. It will happen though - I'm quite determined :)